🎓
Class Discussion / Seminar
Contribute thoughtfully in academic settings
What Comment Coach does for you
Prepare contributions that demonstrate understanding, add analytical depth, and invite further discussion. The coach pushes you past summary-level thinking into genuine analysis.
Your coaching angles
Analytical Observation
Broader Theme Connection
Respectful Challenge
Tap "See Approaches" to see how each angle approaches the same reference. Use them as inspiration, then write your own.
How scoring works here
Depth is weighted highest. Does your comment go beyond summarizing? Does it connect to broader themes? Does it show original thinking? Purely descriptive comments get flagged.
Typical workflow
- Paste the reading excerpt or discussion prompt
- Identify one specific argument, tension, or assumption you want to address
- Write your contribution — connect the text to a larger pattern or question
- Coach it — is your analysis specific enough? Are you going beyond summary?
- Refine and finalize — your contribution should start a conversation, not end one
What makes a great comment
- References the text directly with specific details
- Connects to broader themes or other readings
- Raises a genuine question, not a rhetorical one
- Shows you did the reading deeply, not just skimmed it
Timer zones
≤ 120s — on target
121–150s — slightly over
> 150s — needs trimming